Do you have confidence in Metrorail after Monday's accident?
See Results
Error: Please select a vote.Error: Please enter the text from the image above.Error: No vote was submitted. Please try again.Error: Our log shows that you have already voted once.
  • More Coverage of the Metro Crash

RAW VIDEO: JOHN CATOE ON NTSB RECOMMENDATIONS

NTSB: Signal Failed in DC Metro CrashNTSB: Signal Failed in DC Metro Crash

The National Transportation Safety Board issued nine safety …

Metro Managers Defend Safety SystemMetro Managers Defend Safety System

Metro General Manager John Catoe spent most of Wednesday doing …

RAW VIDEO: CATOE ON WASHINGTON POST REPORT (PART I)

RAW VIDEO: CATOE ON WASHINGTON POST REPORT (PART II)

Metro Trains to Resume Regular SpeedsMetro Trains to Resume Regular Speeds

Metro officials say red line trains will return to their …

Metro Chair Wants to Junk ATC CircuitsMetro Chair Wants to Junk ATC Circuits

On the same day that Metro's general manager reports that 85 …

NTSB: Signal Failed Before Metro CrashNTSB: Signal Failed Before Metro Crash

Signaling equipment that is supposed to detect stopped trains …

Crowded, Slow Metro Frazzle Nerves Crowded, Slow Metro Frazzle Nerves

Tempers are boiling over on Metro's Red Line in the wake of …

Metro Moves To Handle Holiday CrowdsMetro Moves To Handle Holiday Crowds

On Monday, Metro said none of the 1000-series cars had been …

  • Advertisement

DC Metro Track Circuit Problems?

Updated: Thursday, 25 Jun 2009, 12:33 PM EDT
Published : Thursday, 25 Jun 2009, 6:51 AM EDT

Video by Sarah Simmons / myfoxdc

Commuter rail tracks in the nation's capital are studded with devices that detect passing trains and tell them when to stop or slow down. But those devices on the stretch of track near where nine people were killed in a train crash didn't pass tests by investigators.

The tests Wednesday raised the possibility that trains passing through that stretch could have had trouble receiving signals to stop or slow down. Officials stopped short of saying whether the sensors were broken, refusing to elaborate on the "anomalies" that testers found.

"Whether trains are operated in automatic or manual, these circuits are vital," said Debbie Hersman of the National Transportation Safety Board. "We're particularly interested in the speed commands that might be sent from that circuit when there's a train standing on that circuit."


Related Stories:

The fatal victims from Monday's Metro disaster came from all walks of life, but shared a fate none of them could have foreseen when they stepped on board the Red Line on Monday.

 

On Wednesday, workers removed the last of the debris from a devastating D.C. Metro crash that killed nine people and left scores more injured from the scene of the accident.  Watch raw video of the cleanup and see photos here on our website. 

 

Investigators looking into the deadly crash of two Metro transit trains focused Tuesday on why a computerized system failed to halt an oncoming train, even though there is evidence that the operator tried to slow it down.  National Transportation Safety ...

 

Metro trains will be operating on a single track between Fort Totten and Takoma Park Station between 5:00 a.m. AND 10:00 a.m. and again from 3:00 p.m. until 10:00 p.m.  During the hours in between, the tracks will be closed and riders will have to use ...

 

The union that represents Metro's train operators is asking for a series of procedural changes in the operation of the rail system.  The demands come just days after a deadly crash on the Red Line that killed nine people, including the operator of one ...

 

When two D.C. Metro trains collided during rush hour in Northwest Washington on Monday, firefighters rushed to the scene to save as many lives as they could.  One of those firefighters shared this video what happened in the moments after the deadly ...

 

In the wake of the deadly Red Line Metro crash, many people are questioning the safety of the old 1000-series cars.  The National Transportation Safety Board says those cars have little if any survivable space and can collapse in a crash.  Metro says ...

 

A transit operator on the job about three months in the nation's capital had just started her shift and took over an older train that federal safety officials had warned years earlier should be replaced.

MORE DC Metro Crash Stories >>>


Equipment along a 740-foot stretch failed to recognize the testing device, Hersman said. Five other stretches of track, or circuits, in the area of the crash near the Maryland state line showed no problems.

Hersman wouldn't give specifics on what the "anomalies" were or whether investigators think they were occurring before the crash, saying more tests were needed. Investigators planned to test the track with a six-car train Wednesday night.

An engineering professor who's studied transportation safety said that if sensors failed on the track, it could have contributed to Monday's crash, which killed nine people. He emphasized, though, that catastrophic crashes usually can't be blamed on a single factor.

"If the sensors didn't work properly, it deprived (the train operator) of very vital information," said Najm Meshkati, professor of engineering at the University of Southern California. "She was the last layer of defense."

The deadliest crash in Metrorail's 33-year history occurred when a train plowed into another that was stopped. The moving train was operating in automatic mode, which means it was primarily controlled by a computer, although there is evidence the operator tried to slow it down. Since the crash, trains have been manually controlled as a precaution against computer problems.

Hersman said inspectors found 300 feet to 400 feet of markings on the rails, indicating some emergency braking took place before the crash. Hersman also has said the emergency brake control on the moving train was found pushed down, though it's not clear how or when that happened. The operator of the oncoming train was among the dead.

Hersman said investigators hoped to interview the operator of the other train on Thursday, a day after his release from the hospital.

NTSB officials say their investigations can take more than a year.

The cars destroyed in the

crash included some of the oldest in Metro's fleet. Federal officials wanted them phased out because of their tendency to compact in a crash, but Metro officials said the agency has lacked the money for replacements.

Meanwhile Wednesday, a union representing Metro transit workers demanded changes in safety procedures. Jackie Jeter, the union's president, said cars from the aging series involved in the crash should be placed in the middle of trains, rather than at the front or back because they are less stable.

The union also asked that operators be allowed to choose whether to use automatic mode, which is typically employed during rush hour. Jeter demanded that Metro officials not mandate speeds at which trains should travel, saying operators were being pushed to move too fast.

Metro spokesman Steven Taubenkibel said the agency was looking into the union's demands.

The union isn't the only one to raise concerns about running trains in automatic mode.

In Chicago's 'L' train system, operators never use an automatic system, said Robert Kelly, president of the city's transit workers union.

"If it were left to me, I would never have a train operate in automatic mode or autopilot," said Kelly, a former train operator.

"The problem with this job is complacency," he said, noting the risk of problems increases when operators aren't forced to stay alert.

Robert Jones, who retired from Metro after 18 years as a train operator and then came back in 2007 to work part-time, disagreed.

Operators have to keep an eye on hundreds of people at each train station platform during rush hours and prepare to stop for any safety concerns. They also open and close the doors, which requires them to look back from a window to make sure no one gets caught in the doors.

"You have to be aware all of the time," Jones said. "It's a job that requires your full attention."

Metro has said it needs $12 billion over the next 10 years to maintain services and replace aging equipment such as the older rail cars. The agency has long argued the federal government should contribute because its trains serve the capital, and many riders are federal workers.

Last year, Congress approved $1.5 billion in funds over 10 years, but with a condition that the District of Columbia, Maryland and Virginia match the amount. Now that all three jurisdictions served by Metro have agreed, Congress can move forward, officials said.

The region's congressional delegation introduced a measure Wednesday that would finalize plans to provide the funds.

Even with an infusion of cash to order new cars, Metro officials caution that it would still take about five years to get the equipment.

"It's not an off-the-shelf product," Metro spokeswoman Lisa Farbstein said. "It's something that's custom made."

Copyright AP Modified, Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Outbrain
Share
Advertisement
  • Popular Stories Today!
  • Suggested Search
  • Advertisement